7 criteria for testing a project

The Atelier aims to teach a critical approach that can help work on cultural heritage sites.
ICOMOS has identified 7 criteria through which the EU commission can evaluate ex-ante the positive impact of a project that aims at renewing a cultural site. The Atelier adopts these 7 criteria – knowledge-based, public benefit, compatibility, proportionality, discernment, sustainability, and Good Governance – as a filter through which each project must be argued. Students have developed a double work: first, identify the intervention strategy; second, through the critique of their project, verify its effectiveness concerning the 7 criteria.
This exercise aims to teach a method of work that can be applied in our contemporaneity.
The attached slides don't show the project developed during the Atelier; they show the final comment the students have discussed to argue their project.

Atelier project site:
Gamerra Barracks and surroundings in Venaria Reale.

[Cover: La Maison Carrée, photo by Roberta Sassone, Nîmes 2023]

Course:

Atelier Heritage renovation and enhancement project

Professors:

E. Vigliocco, L. Staricco, A. Barreca

Students:

N. Jenabi Shalmani, T. Shamsaie Lashkariani, A. E. Santiago, C. Vasquez, J. Jimenez, N. Stefanov, O. Gucray, N. Arzu Tasin, L. Sureshkumar, D. Esasphelivan, S. Demachkieh, A. A. Petryszyn, K. Kluba, P. Wlodarczyk, A. Razzauti, C. Seif, L. Dequesnes, S. Taajzadeh, S. Mehrara, E. Emirbayer, V. Adam, M. Elhatip, C. Cadena, J. Londono, D. Carneiro Avila, A. K. Eohieldin Mohamed, N. Tabet, M. Shyam, I. S. J. Pulikkottil, M. Velazco Negrete, M. Rimbot, A. Seher Kiziltan, P. Ergene, B. Goshtasbpour, M. E. Abderezaee, M. F. Valim, A. Arasil, G. Lunas, N. Yasar, A. Polanco, R. M. Derveaux, S. Sinnige, C. Calvera, A. Nicolau, M. Hevia, M. Gallego, Y. Zhang, J. He, L. Zotaj, A. Kersin, F. Saba.

Tutors:

R. Ronzani, G. Malavasi

Date:

20 January 2023